Why is it that people use their own personal experiences as solid proof for the existence of their god? ( and no, this is not the same as “eye witness” accounts)
People claim that they have “seen” god, or have seen other divine visions. Some even say that god talks to them. While this may be enough to convince an individual and the religious folk surrounding them that they have had a first hand encounter with god, it is not enough for the majority of the population. In fact, I’m pretty sure that when people go around saying they have seen and heard things that no one else has, they end up in the hospital for a psychological evaluation. I won’t deny that the experience may seem very real for the person going though it, but it doesn’t mean that it is real.
Even when I was involved in the church, I “saw” and “felt” things. In hindsight, I realize now, that I was simply feeding off the emotions and promptings of the people around me.
As far as signs go, I have found that anyone looking for a “sign” from god will find one no matter what. I will use a recent example:
I work with a very religious woman. She shared with me that she and her husband were having some problems. She asked for my advice and I told her that she needed to confront her husband and work it out. Her response was ” I thought about that, and then decided to pray for god to give me a sign so I would know what to do. I told god that if he wanted me to let the issue rest, then make my husband kiss me before he went to work, and my husband did kiss me before he left, so I know god doesn’t want me to bring it up and everything is fine with my husband and I now.”
Now, I know for a fact that my co-worker is a non confrontational person and will do anything to avoid an argument. She also knows that her husband always kisses her when he leaves for work, so she picked a constant to serve as her sign because she knew it would happen anyway, and then she convinced herself that it was really god telling her what to do, thus keeping her out of a situation she wanted to avoid in the first place. She set herself up to get the “answer” she wanted. It’s not god’s handiwork as much as it is manipulation and it certainly offers no proof of the divine.



